Smach “It’s-a-Scam” Z Has A Real Working Prototype

Despite some folks claiming that the portable console Smach Z has been a scam all along, facts keep pushing towards a different narrative (Reminder: I met with Smach Z representatives back in September last year in Tokyo). If it’s a scam, it’s a very elaborate one since they have recently shown an actual working prototype back at the Embedded World exhibition in early March 2019. You can see for yourself the device in action at the hands of attendees.

As you may be aware now the Smach Z is using AMD Ryzen/Vega SOC to drive its graphics capabilities. Here follows a video where a german magazine interviews the Smach Z team (the interview itself is in English). They confirm again that they plan to have a specific Linux distribution for the device at launch (not SteamOS anymore). The device is composed of two PCBs that connect to each other’s. The base is for peripherals and devices, and the other one is for the SOC itself and memory and disk storage.

This opens the possibility of upgrading a new PCB to upgrade the AMD SOC (through Smach Z). While it’s certainly a great idea to think about future updates, the lack of any kind of standard will make this possibility highly dependent on the continued existence of Smach Z, which is far from guaranteed at this stage… so, don’t count too much on it.

While I don’t get the feeling that the project is a scam, the final production is getting delayed further. Backers were supposed to get their device by Q1 2019, and guess what, Q1 2019 is now over and nobody has received one yet. The culprit? Problems with the pre-production boards have arisen – and while I am not privy to the details, not being a backer myself, it’s probably not going to make it to the hands of anyone until later this year, or who knows, even later.

This is not unusual.

I have been following hardware projects in multiple categories for something like 9 years now and this is hardly the first time multiple issues are found at various stages of development. Each issue can cause one or several delays on their own. Software projects are a lot more predictable, since you cna push for a fix in almost no time. When hardware fails or does not work as expected (for example, stability/driver issues are frequent), designing a fix can be time consuming or dependent on a 3rd party, and cause several months before it can be actually addressed and tested again.

The typical rebutal is “oh yeah? How about companies like Samsung which are able to push new smartphones every single year without delay?“. Which is a very, very silly and ignorant comment to make. Samsung has hundreds if not thousands of engineers/designers working full time on every next smartphone model and have their own development facilities to make it possible to test things much faster than your typical small team working from a garage with external suppliers. A better point to make is to ask “How about GPD?” Well, GPD is a much bigger company and working directly from HK/Shenzen which is the center of electronics assembly and supply for the whole world currently – which should present a huge set of advantages when it comes to iterating on designs and finding suppliers for various parts.

Back to Smach Z: having now a real working prototype is a milestone in itself – of course there is still ample chance for the project to fail on the way (more technical issues, running out of funds, a large company introducing a similar device, etc…), and my advice for anyone backing such projects before they release has always been “spend your money as if you were to never see it again“.

For everyone else, it’s safer to wait for a first product to be out and properly tested. But I would say this is now looking more likely than not going to be a real product in the near future.

PS: Needless to say, I have no stake or vested interests in Smach Z (not even a backer).


BoilingSteam lets you access our content for free, but writing articles is a constant investment. We don't use ads or sponsporship, help us make our activities sustainable by donating via Patreon or LiberaPay if you prefer it anonymous. Note that Patreon supporters get the weekly or twice-a-week Proton Deals Newsletter to help them save time and money when buying games for Linux. You can follow what we do via our newsletter, our RSS feed, our Mastodon profile or our Twitter feed. We also have Peertube and Youtube channels. If you'd like to chat, you can also find us on #boilingsteam:matrix.org.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Insider

Yes, more problems and more delays equals more months. This time it has to do with the second memory slot and also some firmware fixes needed due to stability issues. But who knows what other unknown problems will be encountered in the coming months. In the annals of crowdfunding, this one is looking more like the doomed Spectrum Vega+ or the still ongoing saga of Dragonbox Pyra.

Insider

However Dragonbox Pyra had started off with real working prototypes and not “proof of concept”, false prototypes including that laptop powered or non working mockups like Smach Z did. In Dragonbox Pyra’s case even the casing itself took up a lot of time and caused delays due to imperfections. Smach Z’s casing is in the same boat if you had not noticed it at Tokyo Game Show 2018. And if you are wondering how much those tooling and molds costs, check Gamer Nexus video about AMD’s stock cooler production. Also what about that Linux based Smach OS? Yes, talking about… Read more »

Insider

And it got delayed so many times that by now the OMAP5432 can be considered obselete. Their customized Linux operating system and drivers also contributed to those delays. Back to Smach Z, its not the size but the form factor. If you look at all the events from 2017 to 2018, they gave numerous unrealistic timelines as they were never in any position to get it production ready at any time during that period. They hid all of this by keeping updates private and imposing NDAs. Some of those updates have eerie similarities with Spectrum Vega+ saga, particularly pertaining to… Read more »

Roger

This author literally does not understand why Smach Z earned the title of a “scam” in the first place. Smh at this poor attempt at investigative journalism.

Insider

Have you heard the news about GPD Win Max with Ryzen APU recently? Smach Z took so long that now GPD is breathing down their necks. If GPD launches their GPD Win Max first before Smach Z does or not, then it will be very hillarious indeed.